The Best Way to
Sell Your Comics
and Get the Most for Them
Cash offers. Local pickup in Madison. Faster and fairer than shops.
“ Fast, easy, and fair.
⭐⭐⭐⭐”
– Local seller
Hey I’m Chris!
I own and operate Cheddar Comics from my home and I’ve also been collecting comic books for most of my life. What started as a hobby has grown into a full-time business!
I buy and resell comic collections of all sizes — from just a few issues to entire long boxes. My goal is to make the process easier for you than going through local shops, auctions, or the hassle of selling online.
I’ve spent years collecting, studying, and valuing comics, and I bring that knowledge to every collection I see. I’ll give you a fair, no-pressure offer — and in most cases, I’ll pay more than the local shops (Half Priced Books, Comic Book Stores).
Testimonials
“Was looking to sell my collection from the late 80’s and met with Chris. He was a pleasure to deal with and gave me a fair price for my collection. I would recommend Cheddar Comics.”
- Brett Cartwright, Facebook review
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
“Reaching out to Cheddar Comics and meeting Chris restored a little faith in humanity. Well mannered and personable greeting myself and family. Honest and to the point and very knowledgeable discussing the value of my collection keeping a respectable tone and advisement. Please consider Cheddar Comics if you need someone who you can trust.”
— Gregg Scott, Facebook Review
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
“Cheddar Comics is a great place to turn to, rather than second hand stores or Comic Book shops to unload your comics. Easy to work with, no BS. I let go of my full collection of comics and I could not be happier that they will be returning to other collectors. Very pleased and will return!”
— John Karalis, Facebook Review
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
Chris was very responsive and prepared for our meeting. we settled on a fair price. I felt he was honest in his opinions on 1947 comics. Thank you Chris and enjoy your purchase.
— Richard Tuescher, Facebook Review
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
“I will absolutely do business with Cheddar Comics again in the future. I was given a fair price on a lot of comics that were simply taking up closet space. I'm happy they found someone who will enjoy them and connect them with others who collect.”
— Travis Sackett, Facebook Review
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
“Just met with this guy and I have to say that he is awesome! He gave me a better price for my collection than I would have gotten anywhere else. He also donates a lot of stuff to places that get comics to kids. 5 Star status!!”
— Tim Yoston, Facebook Review
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
How It Works
-
REACH OUT
Send me a message using the contact form below. You can include photos, a rough list, or just a quick note about what you have — even if you’re not sure. I’ll get back to you quickly.
-
SET UP A TIME TO MEET LOCALLY
If you're nearby, we can schedule a time to meet in person so I can take a closer look at your comics - either at your home or a public spot. Condition plays a big role in value, so seeing the books in hand helps me give you the most accurate and fair offer possible.
-
GET PAID
Once we agree on a price, you’ll get paid on the spot! I pay in cash (or Venmo, Paypal), and you walk away with money in your pocket and space cleared up at home. Whether you’re selling a few books or an entire collection, I make sure the process is smooth, respectful, and worth your time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of comic books do you buy?
I buy comics from all eras — Golden Age, Silver Age, Bronze, and Modern (so 1940’s to now). I'm especially interested in superhero titles (like Marvel and DC), key issues, full collections, CGC/CBCS slabbed comics, but I’m happy to look at just about anything.
Do you have a store?
I don’t have a physical storefront. I sell comics online and work from home, which allows me to keep things simple and flexible. When buying collections, I typically meet people at a public location or at their home — whichever is more comfortable for you.
How far do you travel to look at collections?
It depends on the size and type of collection. I’m willing to travel a few hours for the right books, but I do ask to see photos or a video walkthrough first. That helps me understand what you have and ensures it’s worth the trip for both of us. I want to value your time — and mine — while making the process as smooth as possible.
Do I need to know what my comics are worth?
Not at all, I’ll help evaluate their condition and value when we connect, and I’ll walk you through the offer.
How do you determine the value?
Comic collection value depends on several key factors — including the number of books, specific titles and issue numbers, condition, and current market demand. I look at all of those things when reviewing a collection. I’ll always explain how I arrive at my offer, and I do my best to be transparent and fair throughout the process.
What do you do with the comics you are unable to sell?
Most collections include some comics that aren’t in demand or are harder to resell — and that’s okay. I donate many of those to local organizations like the Madison Reading Project, which gives books and comics to kids and promotes children’s literacy. I also drop comics off at Little Free Libraries around the area. So even if a book isn’t valuable, it still finds a good home and brings joy to someone else.
Contact Me!
Contact me today for a fair offer on your comics and I'll find them a good home!
or email me at cheddarcomics@gmail.com
